Judge Considers Reduced Sentence For 1999 Murder When Defendant Was 17-Years-Old

Thank you for reading Baltimore Witness.
Consider making a donation to help us continue our mission.

Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Lynn S. Mays heard arguments for the reduction of Davon Alston’s sentence under the Juvenile Restoration Act (JRA) on June 15. The JRA allows adults who were tried as minors to request reductions in their sentences after they have served 20 or more years.

Alston was incarcerated for 25 years for a crime that occurred Nov. 22, 1999, when he was 17; consequently, he is eligible for a reconsideration. He was sentenced to 40 years in prison for the charges of first-degree murder and unlawful possession of a firearm.

Defense attorney Catherine Wooley argued that Alston deserves and is capable of growing from a second chance, noting he has the potential to become a productive member of society.

Alston’s aunt took the stand to express her love for her nephew, and declared she was willing to support him by allowing him to live in her home as long as necessary.

Alston’s father also took the stand, stating that he would support Alston however he could. He also discussed how he and Alston’s mother’s struggled with addiction, as well as an 18-month period of incarceration he experienced during Alston’s childhood that he believes contributed to Alston’s struggles.

Wooley also summoned the manager of a halfway house and rehabilitation center, who described the center’s recovery and reintegration processes and stated that Alston would have a place there upon release.

Wooley emphasized Alston’s had a strong support network and desire for self improvement, including a focus on mental health and an interest in doing home improvement and acquiring other technical skills.

While the prosecution did acknowledge Alston’s young age at the time of his incarceration, as well as the difficult nature of his childhood, they claimed these extenuating factors had already been taken into consideration, as Alston had received only 40 years instead of the life sentence that had been on the table during his original sentencing.

They also cast skepticism on Alston’s progress and self improvement, noting he had assaulted a prison guard only 10 months prior to the hearing.

The case is currently under review.