Jury deliberations got underway on Nov. 18 in the attempted murder trial of 17-year-old defendant Ashad Bennett on before Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Michael A. DiPietro.
The defendant is charged with attempted first-and-second degree murder, first-degree assault, armed robbery, and several firearm related charges. The charges are in connection to a shooting that occurred on the 3600 block of Howard Park Avenue on Dec. 7, 2025.
According to charging documents, the victim was walking home after getting food on the 4700 block of Liberty Heights when he noticed an individual following him. He advised officers that the suspect allegedly pulled out a firearm and demanded that the victim empty his pockets.
When he stated that he would call the police and attempted to flee, the suspect reportedly fired three shots in his direction. No one was injured. On the day after the incident a canvas was conducted and a single 9mm cartridge casing was found on scene.
Months after the incident occurred, the victim allegedly identified the defendant based on a photo array as the individual who shot at him.
On Nov. 18, testimony from a lead detective resumed with the photo array shown to the victim in March 2025. The detective confirmed that he created the array but did not administer it. He also shared that he created a “Be on the Lookout” (BOLO) post citywide which led to the defendant’s arrest. Further, a search warrant was conducted at the location of the arrest and a firearm was recovered, however it was determined to not be related to the case.
During cross-examination, it was revealed that there was not a ShotSpotter alert, only a 911 call made by the victim. The detective also verified that one shell casing was recovered from the scene, although three shots were reportedly fired. The defense attorney confirmed that the spent casing on its own could not identify the defendant.
The second witness called by the prosecution was a detective who conducted the photo array. During cross-examination, he could not remember whether the victim had a visible reaction to the photo of the defendant during the photo array.
In closing, the prosecution stated that everything comes down to the credibility of the victim’s testimony from the day prior. She described the victim to have been emotional and said “he shot me, I could see his face” during his statement. She also claimed that the money stolen was all the victim possessed. The prosecutor underscored the victim’s credibility because he “shared the good and bad when he did not have to”.
The prosecution also said the victim had seen the defendant before on more than one occasion, and that the assault began when the defendant allegedly said “give me something or imma shoot you”. She portrayed the victim as cooperative and stated that even months after the incident he picked out the defendant in-and-out of the courtroom because he “knows exactly who shot him”.
Defense attorney Chelsey Seger argued that the state rests solely on the victim’s testimony, which she described as inconsistent. She stated that there was little to no evidence of positive identification of her client and that the only description given of the suspect was extremely vague.
Further, she asserted that the victim only knew Bennett from the neighborhood and could not offer any specific or unique identifiers. She also claimed that the detective did not observe the victim’s facial expressions during the photo array, however in footage of the interaction it is clear, said Seger, that the victim hesitated when viewing the image allegedly identifying the defendant. Seger concluded that “nobody knows what actually happened” during the incident.