Opening statements were presented before Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Althea Handy on Nov.17 during the third murder trial of 50-year-old Michael Harvey. The defendant is also accused in a mass shooting.
During her opening, the prosecutor told jurors, “This is not law and order; this is real life. It’s going to be obvious that Mr. Harvey planned the killing of Aaron Adams. A person died, and another was paralyzed. The ex-girlfriend of the defendant will testify about the [suspect] minivan and how it belongs to Mr. Harvey.”
“Mr. Harvey is innocent because the law says he is right now. He filed a false police report; find him guilty of that. They didn’t charge him until eight months later because they don’t have any evidence,” defense attorney Jason Otts rebutted.
Harvey stands accused of first-degree murder and conspiracy to murder Aaron Adams,29, along with multiple counts of attempted first-degree murder for three other hospitalized victims in a shooting incident that took place near the 600 Block of Laurens Street on Dec. 12, 2021.
The initial trial ended in a mistrial with a hung jury on Jan. 11, 2024, which resulted in a second trial beginning in April 2024. This second trial resulted in a guilty conviction for the defendant in April 2024, but defense counsel Jason Otts appealed the case to the Maryland Court of Appeals over an improper instruction sent in response to a question from the jury in deliberation.
The jury had asked whether or not the defendant must have specifically intended to kill Adams to convict the defendant of first- degree murder. The court responded “no” to this query, which was determined by the Court of Appeals to be an error. The case was sent back to the lower court for a third trial.
The proceeding is expected to continue Nov. 18.