Trial commenced for a March 2025 mass shooting that left five people injured, and prosecutors allege was part of a planned attack involving Broderick Young, 23. However, the defense argued that there is not enough evidence directly connecting Young to the shooting.
On March 29, 2025, police responded to a shooting near the 5300 block of Frankford Avenue, where a man was found shot while sitting inside his car. Later that day, four additional people were shot near the intersection of Venable Avenue and Greenmount Avenue.
Surveillance footage allegedly showed three gunmen exiting a silver Jeep Compass and firing toward people in the area before leaving the scene. Investigators later connected the Jeep to a stolen vehicle and identified a white Dodge Challenger associated with Young.
Detectives recovered a handgun during a search of a residence in Middle River. Ballistic testing linked the weapon to the shooting, while DNA testing found a mixture consistent with two people, including Young.
The prosecutor described the case as highly circumstantial but argued that the video evidence would show that the shooting was part of a well-executed plan.
The prosecutor said that the suspects arrived in a white Dodge Challenger rented through Enterprise and associated with Young, then fled in a silver Jeep Compass. Investigators later located the Jeep outside an apartment complex.
Furthermore, the prosecutor said that there were 51 pieces of ballistic evidence and that jurors would hear from detectives, shooting victims, crime lab technicians, and an FBI agent. Even though two of the four suspected individuals remain unidentified, the prosecutor maintained that Young was involved as a conspirator.
Defense attorney Natalie Finegar acknowledged that several people were shot but challenged the evidence connecting Young to the shooting.
Finegar argued that DNA evidence must be considered in context. She explained to jurors that its presence on an item does not establish when it was left or prove that someone committed a crime.
She also questioned license plate readers and phone tracking, arguing that no witnesses could place Young at the scene. Finegar told jurors there would be no “a-ha” moment in the case and that the prosecution’s evidence fell short of proving Young’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
The trial is expected to continue tomorrow, Nov. 18, before Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Paul J. Cuczzella.