Search Icon Search site

Search

Jury Finds Defendant Guilty in W. Saratoga Street Murder Retrial

A Baltimore City Circuit Court jury found Donte Brown, 44, guilty of first-degree murder and three firearm offenses on Oct. 29, following a retrial in connection to the 2021 fatal shooting of Tavon Hutton, 22. 

Brown was convicted of first-degree murder, use of a firearm in the commission of a crime of violence, having a handgun on his person and firearm possession with a felony conviction. No verdict is rendered on the two remaining firearm charges.

The verdict followed a retrial before Judge Charles J. Peters and defense attorney Staci Pipkin represented Brown.

According to charging documents, Baltimore Police Department (BPD) officers responded to the 400 block of West Saratoga Street on March 5, 2021, where they discovered Hutton lying on the sidewalk beside his wheelchair, suffering from multiple gunshot wounds. Investigators recovered five 9mm shell casings and a folding knife from the scene.

Surveillance footage allegedly captured two masked individuals approaching Hutton from an alleyway before one engaged him in an argument. The confrontation escalated when the suspected shooter pulled out a handgun and fired multiple shots at Hutton, who reportedly raised his hands before being shot.

Brown was initially convicted of first-degree murder and three firearm offenses on Jan. 31, 2023, and sentenced to life in prison plus 35 years. However, the Appellate Court of Maryland overturned his convictions in March 2025, determining that two surveillance recordings had been improperly admitted without sufficient authentication. The case was subsequently remanded for a new trial.

During opening statements on Oct. 23, prosecutors argued that surveillance footage identified Brown as the shooter, emphasizing the suspect’s distinctive red sneakers, black clothing and chain. She also connected Brown to a SIlver Maserati allegedly used by the suspects to flee the scene, citing DNA evidence recovered from the scene.

Pipkin challenged the prosecution’s identification of her client, arguing that although surveillance footage captured the shooting, it did not establish the perpetrator.  She also emphasized that the red sneakers allegedly worn by the shooter were never recovered from Brown. 

During testimony on Oct. 26, jurors viewed surveillance footage depicting the confrontation and subsequent shooting. Additional footage tracked the suspected shooter toward a nearby gas station, where investigators alleged the Maserati was located. 

During closing arguments on Oct 28, Pipkin highlighted that no witness definitively identified Brown as the shooter. She questioned the reliability of the identification evidence, the investigation into the Maserati and the prosecution’s reliance on the suspect’s appearance and movements. 

Following deliberations, jurors returned a guilty verdict on four counts on Oct. 29, marking Brown’s second conviction in connection with Hutton’s murder.

Brown is scheduled for sentencing on Nov. 23 at 2 p.m., before Judge Peters.

VNS Alert Icon

Stay up-to-date with incidents, updates and stories, as and when they happen.

Donate Star Icon

Donate

Unlike so many organizations involved in criminal justice we have one goal – bring transparency and accountability to the Baltimore criminal justice system.

Help us continue

Give now